The Practical Leadership Newsletter

'Be More Strategic' Isn't Feedback. Here's What It Actually Means

Written by Janet Ply, PhD | Nov 18, 2026, 1:24:45 PM

"Be More Strategic" Isn't Feedback. Here's What It Actually Means.  

 The five behaviors your manager is looking for, and how to start showing them this week. 

by Janet Ply, PhD · The Practical Leadership Newsletter · November 18, 2026

A mid-level technical leader came to our first coaching session and opened with, “I was turned down for a promotion I really wanted. My manager said I need to be more strategic. I don't know what that means or what I'm supposed to do differently. How do I find the balance of being a good leader who gets things done and be strategic at the same time?” The disappointment came through in her voice.

I’ve heard some version of this pretty regularly from the leaders I coach. They were promoted into a leadership role because they did a great job in their previous positions and they tend to double down on what they did well. At some point, however, every leader needs to move from being tactical and hands-on to being more strategic.

What does "being more strategic" even mean?

I learn better from examples so let’s look at a couple to show how one leader gets the job done and another is viewed as strategic.

Same request, two different leaders

On Tuesday afternoon, a VP emails two leaders the same request: "Can you pull together a breakdown of overtime costs by team? Need it by Friday."

Leader A gets to work. She pulls the data, builds the spreadsheet, checks every number twice, and sends it Thursday night. She delivered an accurate report ahead of the deadline with the requested information.

Leader B asks a question first when she gets the request: "Happy to. What decision is this feeding into?"

It turns out that the VP is deciding whether to approve two new hires. So Leader B pulls the same data and provides an accurate and timely report. However, she adds a few lines at the top to shed additional light on the situation. Overtime is primarily used on one team. It's tied to a recurring month-end process. Fixing that process could cut overtime by a third before anyone is hired. Her recommendation: fix the process first, then revisit hiring in 90 days.

Both managers worked hard and delivered high quality reports on time. Only one will be viewed as strategic.

Compare the behavior of both leaders. Leader B looked past the task to the decision behind it. She connected the work to what mattered to the business and brought a recommendation that was the root cause of the problem.

That's the behavior your manager is asking for.

What strategic actually means

Thinking strategically means looking beyond the immediate task to understand what matters to the business, anticipate consequences, and recommend a path forward.

You don't need a five-year plan. You can demonstrate strategic thinking in how you handle the work already on your desk.

Five behaviors your manager is looking for

  1. You connect work to business priorities. Before you start anything significant, you can answer one question: Which business outcome does this move? If you can't answer it, ask before you start.
  2. You ask what decision the work supports. Requests rarely come with context. Strategic leaders go get it. "What will you use this for?" is one of the most valuable questions you can ask.
  3. You look one step downstream. Who else does this affect? What happens next month if we do this? What breaks? You spot problems early instead of reacting after they grow.
  4. You say what should wait. Being strategic isn't doing more. It's choosing the highest value work. When everything feels urgent, you prioritize and explain what matters most, what can wait, and why.
  5. You bring recommendations, not just updates. Instead of "Here's the problem," you say "Here's the problem, here are the options, and here's what I'd do."

You can start putting these into practice tomorrow morning.

Turn vague feedback into specifics

If you've been told to be more strategic, go back to your manager and ask this question:

"When you think of someone who does this well, what's one thing they do that I don't?"

That question does three things. It shows you took the feedback seriously. It turns a vague label into a concrete example. And it gives you a target you can actually hit.

Then review the work you did last week. Rate yourself 1 to 5 on each of the five behaviors above. Where did you score lowest? That's a good starting point. Pick one behavior and practice it on one task this week.

Use AI as your thinking partner

Before your next big assignment, paste this into your AI tool of choice:

"I've been asked to [describe the task]. Help me think strategically about it. Ask me questions, one at a time, to uncover: which business priority this connects to, what decision it supports, who else it affects, what could go wrong downstream, and what I should recommend. Challenge my assumptions. Don't let me off the hook."

Answer honestly. You'll walk into your next conversation with your manager sounding very different.

From vague feedback to trusted judgment

Strategic thinking isn't a gift some people are born with and others aren’t. Like all leadership skills, it can be learned and put into practice.

That's why I built How to Think Strategically and Bring Solutions, a six-week live cohort for people leaders ready to contribute beyond day-to-day execution. Using real situations from your own work, you'll learn to define the real problem, weigh trade-offs, and bring recommendations backed by sound reasoning. You'll also learn when to decide, when to involve others, and when to escalate.

We'll meet one hour/week for a learning lab and have an optional hour for office hours to answer any questions you may have.

Are you the leader who's been told to "be more strategic"? Or the leader who would love to have a team of strategic thinkers? Let's talk. Go to janetply.me and grab time on my calendar.

Janet Ply, PhD
Author, Practical Leadership ~ Creator of the Practical Leadership Accelerator